Membership Required: Only ArtWanted.com members are allowed to post to the message boards.

If you are already a member, please login to the control panel before you post.

If you are not yet a member, click here to join. It is free!
20 January, 2005
  • RQ Trietsch

Latest Comment...

When you go into someones portfolio and they have the ratings turned on, isn't that the same thing as a "Critique"?

Perhaps a "Suggestions" Gallery is needed just for comments and not critiques.

Myself, I find it difficult to post a WIP in the Critiques, because I know it's going to be a whole lot different on the finished end. But then again, comments seems to be what everyone wants.

So again...I think a "Suggestion or Comment" Gallery would eliminate this problem.

Just a thought.

19 January, 2005
  • Mike Sankey
  • 19 Jan 2005
  • 219 Views
  • 8 Comments

Original Post: Artwork Critiques (or comments?)

I was just wondering, should artwork critiques be for works in progress, and pieces not posted in portfolios?

If i see someone posting an image saying 'visit my portfolio for this image' should i go all balls out and then critque them instead of comment on them?

Otherwise Artwork Critques is going to be used as 'hey I've posted a new image!'

It's a small gripe, but I think a valid one.