Latest Comment...

Well said Minnie, I agree. A critique is a tool an artist can use for growth. It is like looking at your work with fresh eyes. There is a difference between a brutal bashing and an honest critique. It doesn't have to come from a professional artist. I'm in school now , and have to sit through critiques constantly. It hurts my ego sometimes, but you have to move passed that to grow. I'm not being bashed, just being given some useful information. I can chose to take it or not, to agree or not. Sadly we had a professor tell us that he would only talk about the good in our work, because he'd seen too many students cry when critiqued. So we were denied this critical sharing of thoughts. If you want nice and sweet, ask your friends and family. Your grandma will always stroke your ego and tell you how wonderful your work is. Does that help you as an artist to grow? If an artist gets defensive with a critique, it's no wonder no one wants to tell you anything negative, it's your loss after all. Again , there is a difference between a bashing and a critique. I'm surprised that some artists love to critique others, but can't stand to be critiqued. It's just weird.

Original Post: What is a good critique?

I have an objection to anonymous judges at art shows and fairs.

I like to know the experience and ability, from my own point of view, of anyone who makes judgements. Not just in artwork critiques, but judgements in general.